Content note: In this article I discuss ways that the state education system where I…
set up to succeed
7.
set up to succeed
Content note: in this article I discuss some ideas around making school and learning more accessible
Read more: set up to succeedDo you notice the use of buzzwords in our society when we’re talking about disability and support needs? I do. Recently I’m noticing some buzz phrases around schools and education. One of them is “set them up to succeed”. The implication being if we do things a different way than typically suggested we are setting up to fail. And often the strategies suggested to set a child up to succeed are strategies that coerce the child to do things the way everyone else is doing them.
But are we really “setting them up to fail” when we do things atypically?
Let’s think about it in the context of partial enrolment arrangements at school.
I frequently hear people say “we don’t want to set them up to fail” when a request is made for formalised partial attendance arrangements at school.
“They need to know this is the expectation”,
“They have to learn to do it the way we do it”,
or “everyone else does it this way”.
“How are they ever going to get a job if they can’t even attend school normally?”
But is doing things atypically setting someone up to fail when they have a neurotype that is atypical?
The reason that there’s so much repetition and drilling at school is that we’re trying to force a brain to learn something that is not interested in. So it’s hard for all students. No one learns easily when they aren’t interested in the subject matter!
For a neurodivergent student that process is actually more difficult and tiring than for a neurotypical student, in that they are already processing so much sensory input, language input, and experiencing nervous system dysregulation. Trying to learn under those circumstances is very difficult, even before being asked to learn something that isn’t interesting!!
From my experience, and based on what I have seen in the past, the neurodivergent children who are pushed to do things because “that’s the way we do it”, or “we want them to keep up with their peers”, are the ones that burn out and move into periods of what people call “school refusal”.
But the students that are supported to take some days off when they communicate that they need them, or to attend a shorter day at school on a fairly regular basis as part of their enrolment plan, tend to be the students that manage the requirements of school in a way that doesn’t destroy their well-being.
Planned down time is an access requirements for neurodivergent students.
Without it we cannot reasonably expect them to show up and be present during typical hours and to engage with learning in the so called typical way with their atypical brain and nervous system.
Failing to allow for planned down time is when we set them up for failure.
There is something else to keep in mind, particularly for very young students. You may have heard that research has shown that for your average human to learn a new skill, it takes 400 repetitions…. unless they are learning through play, and then it takes about 10 repetitions.
So when we take children from preschool and long daycare into kindergarten in a primary school setting, they are moving overnight from an active and engaging play based learning strategy to a sedentary instruction based learning strategy. Instantly we are demanding more of their cognitive energy, more of their physical energy, and more of their emotional energy. It’s no wonder that even if they did manage to do a full day at daycare that they cannot manage a full day at school, because the requirements are completely different! Yet we seem to be unwilling to acknowledge this and prefer instead to say the child is being non-compliant.
I think one of the things about non-compliance is that there are ways of being non-compliant that are considered offensive because they are aggressive, demanding, and maybe demeaning or condescending. We don’t respond well to that.
But assertive non-compliance and creative non-compliance are not so offensive and people can recognise in that a kind of spark, a kind of joy. I think people respond well to that.
But again it circles back to having to have the right self-care practices in place that your non-compliance can be assertive rather than aggressive. Anyone with a barrel of unmet needs they are carrying around is going to present more distressed behaviours. They will naturally be more aggressive in communicating their needs. Whereas somebody who has good self-care practices and good supports around them can bring the non-compliance in assertive and creative ways. Non-compliance could be less rigid when coming from a place of self care as well.
So if we take all of these things into account, it’s easy to see how offering a more flexible model of learning, that includes the option for reduced, or atypical, hours of attendance for students who do better with more downtime, is actually a way to set them up for success. And for success beyond school as well. A young person who had the opportunity to learn about their support needs as a child and to become confident communicating those needs assertively, is much more likely to be able to choose the kind of work they can realistically do and do well.
This is setting someone up to succeed.

This article is featured exclusively at hellomichelleswan.com.
The content of this article is the intellectual property of Michelle Swan, and is copyright.
Permission to reproduce this article, in part or in whole, can be sought by emailing contact@hellomichelleswan.com
click here to read full disclaimer, attributions and acknowledgements page (opens in a new tab)

